22.Edited Works and Conference Proceedings.
The archives and records management field has long advanced its knowledge via
conferences or edited compilations of essays.
Careful analyses of the primary journals reflect that a considerable
portion of the content published in these outlets derive from conferences and
special meetings. Some of these have
become noteworthy benchmarks in transitions in practice and theory or gained
attention because of controversial or contested viewpoints. Others have merely reflected current
practice, much like the basic manuals.
However, such publications cannot be ignored because they often provide
important commentary on the more basic writings or provide reports on research,
case studies, and other issues serving to advance practice.
23.There
are many examples of such publications providing additional insights into
archival work. Some of these volumes have knit together essays in order to form
a basic textbook, such as Maygene F. Daniels and Timothy Walch, eds., A Modern Archives Reader: Basic Readings
on Archival Theory and Practice
(Washington, D.C.: National Archives and Records Service, 1984), a
volume still in print and in use even though it is very outdated (the Society
of American Archivists is currently preparing a new version of this reader, a
much needed replacement). Some of these kinds of volumes now provide useful
historical texts, such as Richard H. Lytle, ed., Management of Archives and Manuscript Collections for Librarians
(Chicago: Society of American Archivists, 1980; org. Pub. 1975), an excellent
view into prevailing archival practices of a quarter of a century ago. Laura B. Cohen, ed., Reference Services for Archives and
Manuscripts (New York: Haworth Press, Inc., 1997) and Elsie Freeman Finch,
ed., Advocating Archives: An Introduction to Public Relations for Archivists
(Metuchen, New Jersey: Society of American Archivists and the Scarecrow Press,
Inc., 1994) both provide, for example, groups of writings that add to the existing literature on
reference and advocacy. The Finch
volume is, moreover, probably the best
set of writings on the archival function of advocacy. The Cohen volume is intended to replace Lucille Whalen, ed., Reference
Services in Archives (New York: Haworth Press, 1986), and it is a far
superior work. By reading this volume
and the Whalen collection of essays one gains a sense of immense changes in how
archivists view reference.
24.Not
surprisingly, electronic records management has been the topic of many
conferences resulting in conference proceedings and edited works. There are
many important conference proceedings on electronic records, including Cynthia
J. Durrance, comp., Management of
Recorded Information: Converging Disciplines; Proceedings of the International
Council on Archives’ Symposium on Current Records, National Archives of Canada,
Ottawa May 15-17, 1989 (New York: K. G. Sauer, 1990); Margaret Hedstrom,
ed., Electronic Records Management Program Strategies, ed. Margaret Hedstrom
(Pittsburgh, PA: Archives and Museum Informatics, 1993); and Stephen Yorke,
ed., Playing for Keeps: The Proceedings of an Electronic Records Management
Conference Hosted by the Australian Archives Canberra, Australia, 8-10 November
1994 (Canberra: Australian Archives, 1995). The Hedstrom and Yorke volumes are especially noteworthy because
of the essays from many different perspectives and the capturing of the sense
of controversies over different approaches to electronic records management.
An extremely useful
teaching tool and resource is a CD publication by Cohasset Associates, Inc.
produced for the US Patent and Trademark Office, Managing Electronic Records
National Conference: The Best of the First Five Years of the MER 1993-1997
[1999]. The CD includes 28 talks
grouped by five areas – electronic records management issues and concepts;
classification, indexing, scheduling, storage, and access; application issues
and concerns; legal issues; and management concerns. What you get is the recording of the speaker’s actual
presentation, and the pacing with the presentation of PowerPoint slides. Some of the best-known authorities are
represented on this CD, including Charles Dollar, Gregory Hunter, John
McDonald, and Robert F. Williams. The
CD publication is free either through the US PTO or Cohasset Associates.
25.The
archival profession has also supported the collecting of essays by or about
archival pioneers, providing a unique set of writings on archival management
with a historical perspective. The
accumulated writings of Margaret Cross Norton, collected and edited by Thornton
Mitchell and mentioned above, is the prime example of this type of
publication. Barbara
L. Craig, ed., The Archival Imagination: Essays in Honour of Hugh A. Taylor
(Ottawa: Association of Canadian Archivists, 1992) is an important work with
many important contributions in it, especially Terry Cook’s essay on macro-appraisal.
One of the best sources on Ernst Posner, one of the leading archival
theorists and historians of the twentieth century, is Ken Munden, ed., Archives and the Public Interest:
Selected Essays by Ernst Posner (Washington, D.C.: Public Affairs Press,
1967), conveniently collecting some of his seminal writings. It would be useful to have more of these
kinds of volumes available to the profession, especially of the more recent
pivotal figures such as Margaret Hedstrom, Terry Cook, and James O’Toole – all
projects that are eminently doable since these individuals are quite active and
could undertake the work. Each of these
individuals has been as influential on archival theory and practice in the
1980s as Schellenberg or Jenkinson were more than a half-century ago.
26.Conference
proceedings or edited works on archival appraisal and descriptive standards
also have moved professional discussions on these issues to new and interesting
levels. Terry Eastwood, ed., The Archival Fonds: From Theory to Practice,
(Ottawa: Bureau of Canadian Archivists, 1992) is an example of a series of
works on Canadian archival description standards that has energized discussion
about this area. Murtha Baca, ed. Introduction
to Metadata: Pathways to Digital Information (Los Angeles: Getty
Information Institute, 1998) is part of a series of Getty publications
providing a practical introduction to the descriptive management of digital
information, including electronic records and Web pages including electronic
records. An excellent set of essays
introducing the concept and importance of authority control for access to
archival records is Avra Michelson, ed.
Archives and Authority Control, Archival Informatics Technical
Report, 2 (Summer 1988). A number of archivists have used edited works to focus on
critical issues and challenges facing the profession. Joan D. Krizack,
ed., Documentation Planning for the U.S. Health Care System (Baltimore:
Johns Hopkins University Press, 1994) builds on the earlier appraisal work done
in the realm of scientific, medical, and technology to examine how complex
aspects of the American health care system will, or can, be adequately
documented. Nancy E. Peace, ed., Archival Choices:
Managing the Historical Record in an Age of Abundance (Lexington: D.C. Heath, 1984) is an excellent example of
how some edited works have played substantial roles in reformulating basic
archival functions such as appraisal.
The Peace volume was a benchmark effort in the early 1980s to develop new appraisal approaches, especially to
bring into the mix lesser-known archival appraisal methods from Europe. Lawrence J. McCrank, ed., Archives
and Library Administration: Divergent Traditions and Common Concerns (New
York: Haworth Press, 1986) was another
effort to explore the relationships between archivists and librarians as a time
when more archivists were beginning to work in libraries and when archival
education was shifting to schools of library and information science. This collection remains the best probe into
the relationship between the disciplines.
27.Such
edited works have also been an important venue for making the ideas of
archivists in other nations more readily available on an international
level. The Australians have been
especially adept in producing volumes of collected writings on seminal topics,
such as the two publications exploring fundamental aspects of the record and
recordkeeping systems -- Sue McKemmish and Frank Upward, eds. Archival
Documents: Providing Accountability Through Recordkeeping (Melbourne:
Ancora Press, 1993) and Sue McKemmish and Michael Piggott, eds., The Records Continuum: Ian Maclean and
Australian Archives First Fifty Years (Clayton, Australia: Ancora Press in
Association with the Australian Archives, 1994). A similar volume on the contributions by Canadians on archival
theory, with a focus on provenance, is Tom Nesmith, ed., Canadian Archival
Studies and the Rediscovery of Provenance (Metuchen, N.J.: Scarecrow Press,
1993), an important contribution marred only by the lack of an index that would
have knitted together the essays in thematic ways. Finally, another groundbreaking group of essays, commissioned as
part of a conference, is James M. O’Toole, ed.
The Records of American Business (Chicago: Society of American
Archivists, 1997). This volume is
particularly relevant for corporate records managers because it examines the
value of business records from a variety of perspectives.
28.Corporate
archives and archival history have become a frequent topic of inquiry in
specially focused conferences. An
English publication, “Pioneering New Frontiers”: An International Exploration of Current Initiatives in Business
Archives: Proceedings of the Business
Archives Council Annual Conference 1997, is the product of a joint
conference of the US Business History Conference, the UK Association of
Business Historians and the Business Archives Council held in Glasgow in July
1997. The volume includes essays on
de-accessioning, electronic finding aids and the archives of multinationals and
small businesses. M. V. Roberts, ed., Archives
and the Metropolis: Papers Delivered at the ‘Archives and the Metropolis’
Conference, 11-13 July 1996, organised by London Metropolitan Archives, the
Corporation of London Records Office, Guildhall Library and the Centre for
Metropolitan History (London:
Guildhall Library Publication in association with the Centre for Metropolitan
History, 1998) is an intriguing, if uneven, collection of essays providing
histories of archives in cities, the development of non-government archives
located in cities, and the use of municipal records for writing urban
history. Some of the essays are
excellent analyses, with important viewpoints to offer, such as Thomas
Behrmann’s comparison of medieval “communal record-keeping” in Genoa and
Lubeck. Such publications, providing
reasonably quick references of important thinking going on in archival circles,
continue to provide challenges to established principles and practices most
generally reflected in the basic manuals and textbooks.